murder trial housing: trouble with their neighbors in the demolition work

Contents of incident

As for the plaintiff W married couple as for the 1st floor at the parking zone of reinforced concrete structure, the 2nd and 3 floor have lived in the residence of the woodwork.It was decided that the house of next door rebuilds, dismantling construction started.After construction starting, often there was the vibration, cracking had occurred in the tile of the external wall.Improvement of construction method was requested to the dismantling trader, but from the engineering work store of the original receiving it could continue job without answer coming.After all construction ended without many explanations, when it tries inspecting the external wall for the second time, in the external wall tile of the 3rd floor cracking was found at the place where it reaches.The W married couple assumed, that serious damage was worn, the construction company, designated the dismantling trader and the client as the defendant vis-a-vis cracking, appealed compensation for damage claim to the courthouse.

Insistence of plaintiff

The defendants geological survey before the construction starting construction, water content many soft stratigraphic constitution you had known the construction method which responds to that in spite, was not done.The damage which the plaintiff sustains reaches to 30,000,000 Yen.

The insistence of defendant

The building of the plaintiff W residence earthquake-proof characteristic is insufficient.The laminating rubber has not entered between the 1st floor and the 2nd floor, as for the external wall of 2.3 floor part the big tile pasting is the expansion joint is not provided in spite.As for cracking, being something which it occurs from the material and aged deterioration of the tile, the vibration which accompanies dismantling construction is not cause.because the cause to the building structure, negligence should be.

result of building appraisal

cause of the cracking is due to shock and vibration stress amplitude and the transverse wave (internal forces acting in the precursor) surface wave is transmitted with, member of the tensile force structure(pull-out force against the force of compression)has occurred because some.

1chi piloti haunch there is no easy shaking in a state of. 2not in the bed floor but should give the anti-vibration. you are using a vertical shape of the outer wall tile is easy to curvature also.

judgment of the court

defendants can be inferred and that caused the vibration corresponds to the time of dismantling. plaintiff alsoWbuilding of stiffness and vibration absorbing performance of piloti is missing. from this that the percentage of comparative fault5which is equivalent to assign. and therefore1500plaintiff million yenWplease pay.

this incident prevented this way! to next page

learning to this incident

if you are a new construction, if the old building adjacent to the general house survey to the. there is a need for research especially if concrete is particularly new buildings. house research is often made from the vacant lot after the demolition. consideration must be given to the ambient surrounding the site, such as descriptions and curing in a sheet-greeting to a neighbor, even when only dismantling.

this incident soft ground defects on the structure of the building next door and, mistake, such as selection of exterior wall tile is now coupled with disaster. you say that this incident caused the contractor has overlooked these guidelines.

since the main building contractor and not leave it to, asked the main responsibility will be built. flow of construction and construction make the building is to some extent has been established, environment of the construction site is different from door to door. the contractor is preferred because you can easily rational way, contractor chooses to read the surrounding environment, i want to choose the neighborhood where you can care to.

the main building is also important to tell if there is information before construction of the unique characteristics and neighborhood conditions, such as land that was also noticed. contractor will be an important point when choosing a reliable builder whether to cope with and listen to me at this time.

the contents of this incidentH18years6month25has been the case files of newspaper articles referring to the sun housing.

links and reference check of the term

reference link
not suitable for house building in trouble
1ranked # is the surrounding environment! house building to learn from failure case failure had overlookedTOP4
murder trial housing: when the neighbor sued by the color of the exterior wall?